My Learning Source › Workshops & Articles

Pennsylvania's June 30 Homeschool Evaluation: Who Can Evaluate, What They Check and How to Choose

By My Learning Source · November 21, 2026 · Guides, Tips

Pennsylvania doesn't ask the school district to judge your homeschool. It asks a qualified evaluator. Every year, each home education student must be interviewed and have their portfolio reviewed, and the evaluator's written certification goes to the superintendent by June 30. PDE's home education page says Act 196 of 2014 made the qualified evaluator's evaluation "the required proof that an appropriate education has taken place." Here's how to pick one and what to expect. Our Pennsylvania Homeschool Options guide covers the rest of the law.

The five ways an evaluator qualifies

PDE's Home Education and Private Tutoring Guide lists the routes under 24 P.S. § 13-1327.1(e):

  • A licensed clinical psychologist.
  • A school psychologist.
  • A Pennsylvania-certified teacher with two years of grading experience at the level evaluated — elementary (K–6), secondary (7–12) or both.
  • A nonpublic school teacher or administrator with two years of teaching experience in a Pennsylvania public or nonpublic school within the last ten years, at the level evaluated.
  • A person with other qualifications, at the supervisor's request and with the prior consent of the superintendent of your district of residence.

"Grading experience" has a definition. The statute, as PDE quotes it, means evaluating "classwork, homework, quizzes, classwork-based tests and prepared tests" in core subjects at that level — English, math, science, geography, history and civics for elementary, with additions such as foreign language and higher math for secondary. PDE adds that a certified teacher's experience counts wherever it happened, including in a private tutoring program.

Two rules surprise people. Evaluators don't have to keep up Act 48 continuing-education hours; PDE says the law specifically exempts them. And the evaluator can never be you or your spouse. PDE's diploma definitions page quotes the statute: "In no event shall the evaluator be the supervisor or their spouse."

The 'other qualifications' route

This one depends entirely on your superintendent. PDE says acceptance is "completely at the discretion of the superintendent," and lists examples of requests it has seen: college professors, teachers certified in other states, experienced homeschool parents, professional curriculum providers and teachers in umbrella schools. If you want to use someone like this, ask for consent well before the evaluation is due — PDE's advice — and get the answer in writing.

The superintendent can't veto a qualified evaluator

For the first four routes, the choice is yours. PDE: "The choice of evaluator selected by the supervisor cannot be denied as long as that individual meets the vocational criteria." The district may verify credentials. PDE explains how: certified teachers and school psychologists are checked online through the Teacher Information Management System, clinical psychologists through state license verification, and nonpublic teachers through their school, by phone or a letter on letterhead. PDE suggests evaluators sign with a credential block — name, PPID or license number, and where and what they taught — so the district can check quickly.

What the evaluation must certify

The law asks for one conclusion: whether an appropriate education is occurring. The evaluation has to be annual and written, and based on an interview with the child and a review of the portfolio. "Appropriate education" means three things, per PDE's guide:

  • Instruction in the required subjects for the child's level.
  • Instruction for the required time — 180 days, or 900 hours (K–6) or 990 hours (7–12).
  • Sustained progress in the overall program, which PDE describes as moving through the mandatory courses so the student will complete them within the current level.

In grades 3, 5 and 8 the evaluator will also look for the reading and math test results, and PDE's policy is that the testing should be documented in the evaluation report. Your evaluator may ask who administered or proctored the test.

When it's due and who pays

The supervisor — not the evaluator — sends the evaluation to the superintendent by June 30. A program that doesn't run the full year should send it at the end of the program. PDE's advice is to "identify an evaluator very early in the school year and schedule an appointment," so the evaluation isn't late. The parent pays any evaluator's fee; PDE says so directly.

If June 30 passes with no evaluation on file, the superintendent must send a certified letter, and you then have 10 days from receipt to submit it before the school board provides for a hearing. That's a backstop, not a plan.

Finding an evaluator

PDE "does not keep a list of evaluators." Its suggestions: ask other homeschooling families, search online for Pennsylvania homeschool evaluators, ask your district for a recommendation, or check homeschool organizations, several of which list evaluators. The evaluator doesn't have to live near you. Questions worth asking before you book:

  • Which qualification route do you meet, and at which level — K–6, 7–12 or both?
  • Do you meet in person, and how long does the interview and review take?
  • What should the portfolio include, and how far ahead should we send it?
  • Will you list the courses you reviewed, signed, each high school year?
  • Will you co-sign a supervisor-issued diploma if you are our twelfth-grade evaluator?

Think ahead to twelfth grade

For a supervisor-issued diploma, only the twelfth-grade evaluator may co-sign — the one whose evaluation was submitted for the graduation year. PDE warns that if that evaluator won't sign and their evaluation has already gone to the superintendent, "a state-recognized diploma issued by the supervisor is no longer possible." Ask before senior year, and pick a secondary-level evaluator. PDE also says a parent may want two documents: a detailed evaluation listing the courses for your records and a simpler one for the superintendent stating only whether an appropriate education occurred.

A family choosing an evaluator

Renee homeschools a ninth grader and a sixth grader in Tioga County. Her longtime evaluator, a certified elementary teacher, couldn't evaluate high school work. In September, Renee found a retired high school chemistry teacher with a Pennsylvania certificate and years of grading secondary science and math, confirmed she'd sign yearly course lists and a diploma in four years, and booked both kids' appointments for early June. The elementary teacher kept the sixth grader. Both evaluations reached the superintendent by mid-June.

(A composite example — names and details are illustrative, drawn from situations homeschool families commonly describe.)

Evaluation checklist

  • Evaluator qualifies by one of the five routes, at the right level.
  • Not the supervisor or the supervisor's spouse.
  • Superintendent's written consent in hand if you're using "other qualifications."
  • Appointment booked months ahead; portfolio ready.
  • Written evaluation certifies whether an appropriate education occurred.
  • Supervisor sends it to the superintendent by June 30; keep a copy and the delivery date.
  • High schoolers: signed course list each year and a diploma conversation before senior year.

Our Pennsylvania vendor directory lists evaluators and testing providers, and the community is the place to ask local families for recommendations. A listing isn't an endorsement — always confirm an evaluator's qualification route yourself.

My Learning Source is an independent marketplace and is not affiliated with the Pennsylvania Department of Education, any Pennsylvania school district or intermediate unit, or the Pennsylvania General Assembly. This is general information, not legal advice. Confirm current evaluator rules with PDE's Home Education and Private Tutoring Guide and your district before you rely on them. Family examples are composites, not real individuals.


More from the marketplace

Loading the full experience… If it does not appear, this article is fully readable above.